Before getting into medical school, I spent several months in South America, mostly in Brazil. Knowing I wanted to practice medicine, particularly among those most in need, I sought out opportunities to shadow doctors and learn about their practice and the illnesses they were seeing. I wanted to understand things beyond my limited view of the world from Saskatchewan. I spent time learning about conditions like Chagas Disease and malaria with general practitioners in clinics in the Northeast and the Amazon.
In São Paulo, I spent a day shadowing a head and neck cancer surgeon. In the morning, he put in a few obligatory hours at a public hospital. A couple of dozen patients waited on benches in hallways of peeling paint outside his office. They had some of the most advanced pathology I’ve ever seen. Baseball-sized neck masses, holes in cheeks; startling stuff. The surgeon explained that people presented much later in the public system due to long wait times and a lack of diagnostic resources. Many came to care only after it was too late. He would offer what care he was able, acknowledging the futility between the rushed visits and expressing his frustration with limited resources and poor-quality care.
That same afternoon, I went with him to a private hospital. Oak-lined walls with gold trim, plush couches in the lobby, brand new equipment in every exam room; it felt more like a five-star hotel than a hospital. Lunch at the cafeteria was the fanciest meal I had the whole time I was in South America. The surgeon explained to me that this was the rewarding work, that here he could give his patients his best. He also got paid far more than for his obligatory hours in the public hospital. He said he knew it was important to keep requiring all the doctors to split their time between the public and private system. He also admitted that he, like most of his colleagues, did the bare minimum, spending as much time as they could get away with offering private care.
Earlier this year, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith announced a plan to undermine the principles and practice of Medicare. Last month, Bill 11 came into effect in Alberta, allowing “dual practice.” This means that physicians can work in the public system and directly charge patients for private care. For now, the practice is limited to surgeries and requires those surgeons to spend some of their time in the public system.
This is a sharp departure from the rules to date in Canada. While physicians in every province but Ontario have had the option to opt out of the public system and charge patients directly, they can’t keep one foot in and one foot out. The Alberta system, which likely violates the Canada Health Act, allows doctors to decide who they’ll bill the government for and who they’ll charge directly.
The government is pitching this as a way of reducing surgical wait times in the public system. They will get longer. The evidence for that from experiments in Canada and around the world is clear, and well-described in this Edmonton Journal article by Danyaal Raza and Braden Manns. In South America, Europe and Australia, dual practice systems have failed to improve wait times and have eroded public care.
Introducing dual practice doesn’t reduce the number of patients in need, it just re-orders them, with ability to pay now trumping medical need. The money spent by wealthier patients to be seen first doesn’t magically increase the number of doctors, operating rooms or nursing staff. It just means those less urgent and simpler surgeries are done first, while those in greater need now wait for a decreased number of public spots.
Meanwhile, the lure of greater income draws specialists to spend more time on their private practice than in the public system. Countries around the world, including Brazil, have tried to implement rules that require a portion of their time in the public system, but none have succeeded. Physicians spend more time doing easier cases for more money, and it’s not hard to see why, especially when the public system is genuinely struggling to keep up.
Introducing dual practice doesn’t reduce the number of patients in need, it just re-orders them, with ability to pay now trumping medical need.
As SFU professor and health policy analyst Karen Palmer told the CBC, “There is no country in the world that allows dual practice ... that has found a way to eliminate its harmful effects even with regulation.” She also pointed out that it can lead doctors to inflate public wait times, “It incentivizes physicians to increase their public wait times so that patients feel that they sort of have no choice but to pay privately.” The increased income for some doctors will also drive up prices in the public system as private payment is pitted against public care.
And herein lies the vicious cycle: the more we remove doctors from the public system, the worse it will get, and the more people will throw up their hands and say “see, Medicare doesn’t work.” This leads to further erosion of commitment to the shared system as influential taxpayers ask why they’re paying twice and pressure the government to further distance itself from universal care funded through taxation.
So, at a time when the public system is struggling to meet capacity, Danielle Smith has chosen to make it worse. Physician leaders at the Canadian Medical Association have spoken out against this move and Canadian Doctors for Medicare is urging the Prime Minister to intervene. Sadly, we have seen no serious response from the federal government. One worries that Smith’s other gambit, allowing a referendum on a possible path to Alberta separating from Canada, is working as the federal government is afraid to have any conflict with the province even if the health of Albertans will suffer as a result.
The answer is not to say everything is fine. The health system is struggling, and the reasons for that are complex. We should never stand up and defend a failing status quo. We need to be seeking innovative solutions to improve care delivery and access.
Raza and Manns identify several options to reduce wait times and improve care: “Surgical wait lists are too long. The evidence-based solutions are known: centralized intake with team-based care, single wait lists, extended operating hours, and investments in multidisciplinary programs for chronic conditions like arthritis that reduce unnecessary surgeries altogether. Beyond the operating room, that also means expanding pharmacare to provinces that have yet to see its benefits and delivering on the promised $3.2-billion primary care fund.”
We should work to make things better, and we definitely shouldn’t accept so-called solutions that will make things worse. The path Smith has Alberta on, holding her own people hostage to keep herself in power, will damage health care in that province and have spillover effects across the country. We are a long way from the disparities I saw as a student in Brazil, but it is decisions like these that make that a possible future for Canada. The Prime Minister does Canada no favours if he rolls over on a scheme that undermines Medicare, one of the social policies that holds us together, that symbolizes the care and concern Canadians have for each other. He has a reputation as a decisive leader. It’s time for him to speak up and for his government to enforce the Canada Health Act and lead on preserving and improving a health system that serves people based on what care they need, not how much money they make.



Thanks Ryan. This is really important information, that people need to know about.
Thank you Ryan for calling for the protection of our Canada Health Act. Our collective voices must reach our federal government to defend our beloved medicare system, based on greatest medical need, not ability to pay for care.